NFL free agent Tyreek Hill was in a Florida courtroom on Thursday to face the OnlyFans model he’s accused of injuring during an impromptu football lesson in 2023.
Hill was originally sued by model and influencer Sophie Hall in February of 2024 for allegedly breaking her leg at his house the previous June. Hall, 36, claimed in her lawsuit that the free-agent wide receiver, 32, shoved her to the ground in a ‘fit of anger’ after she ’embarrassed’ him during a casual training session at his Florida mansion.
Now, according to Hill’s lawsuit, she has pins in her leg and remains in persistent pain following reconstructive surgery.
On Thursday, Hill’s attorney Robert Horwitz told the Fort Lauderdale courthouse that Hall did not seek treatment for 30 days and actually had sex with the NFL star twice soon after suffering her injury.
‘She had sex with Mr. Hill twice,’ Horwitz told the court on Thursday, as seen by CBS Miami cameras. ‘She then goes ATV riding, fishing.’
Hall defended her $50,000 lawsuit by painting herself as a single mother who, prior to becoming an OnlyFans model, struggled to make a living by cleaning houses, braiding hair and selling hair bows.
NFL free agent Tyreek Hill (pictured center) was in a Florida courtroom on Thursday to face the OnlyFans model he’s accused of injuring during an impromptu football lesson
Sophie Hall (pictured) claimed in her lawsuit that Tyreek Hill shoved her to the ground in a ‘fit of anger’ after she ’embarrassed’ him during a casual training session at his Florida mansion
His turbulent tenure in Miami ended in February when he was released by the Dolphins following surgery to repair multiple knee ligaments. He has not been medically cleared yet
‘I ended up being a single mom and I did everything… what I could to make money to provide for [my children],’ she told the jury.
Local10 reported that Hall’s lawyer, Jonathan Gdanski, told jurors during opening statements that the case ‘is about an aggressive act.’
‘What happened was Sophie Hall, this woman, moved him back,’ Gdanski said. ‘They giggled, they laughed.’
Standing just 5ft 8in to Hall’s 6ft 1in frame, Hill was left ‘humiliated’ by the incident, according to Gdanski, who said the receiver quickly switched positions and shoved the plaintiff to the ground.
‘Before anything else, at the force that Sophie felt from Tyreek coming at her, she is in excruciating pain,’ Gdanski said.
Horwitz disputed this version of events, claiming Hall hurt herself by tripping over Hill’s dog. Additionally, Horowitz argued, Hall’s participation in the drill was voluntary and she understood there would be physical contact.
The trial is set to resume Friday morning.
In a previous deposition, Hill explained he had invited Hall to his home to satisfy his ‘fetish’ for taller women. Still, Hill denied being especially attracted to Hall, who sells ‘tall girl content, BBW, b/g, crushing, face-sitting, goddess worshipping’ and ‘giantess vids’ according to her subscriber-only page.
Hill denied being especially attracted to Hall (pictured), who sells ‘tall girl content, BBW, b/g, crushing, face-sitting, goddess worshipping’ and ‘giantess vids’ on her subscriber-only page
As shown by CBS Miami, Hall’s legal team provided X-rays showing the screws in her leg
The 6ft 1in, 250lb-plus influencer bills herself as ‘You’re favorite Blue eyed Tall Goddess with the most amazing curves’ and offered a ‘free nude tape’ and a free 30-day trial
Hill won a legal battle against Hall in March when the Florida judge denied her attorney’s bid to force him to take a psychological examination focused on his history with women. He was previously accused of domestic violence by the mother of three of his children and pleaded guilty to domestic assault and battery by strangulation in 2014.
More recently, his estranged wife Keeta Vaccaro, 29, accused the scandal-plagued athlete of punching her, ripping out her hair and spitting in her face in 2025 divorce documents.
Hill has denied Vaccaro’s allegations.
His turbulent tenure in Miami ended in February when he was released by the Dolphins following surgery to repair multiple knee ligaments. He has not been medically cleared to return, but is expected to draw some interest as a free agent when he does.
ESPN’s Chiefs insider Nate Taylor puts the chances at Hill returning to Kansas City this season at better than 50 percent. Hill previously won a Super Bowl alongside Patrick Mahomes in Kansas City before being traded to Miami and signing a four-year, $120 million extension.
Hill has earned roughly $146 million in salary across 10 NFL seasons.
